kay, Sam,” the designer began, “can you explain this? …please.”
“Well…” Samdel was not sure how to respond. He quickly remembered what the assignment had actually been and felt ashamed for the scribbles he brought. “Well,” he proceeded, “I guess I don’t really have an excuse, I just got carried away drawing and, well, I suppose I forgot the to do what you told me. I’m sorry…”
His head hung low, and he could feel the nervous tensions building within him until the pressure brought a fuzzy cloudiness to the front of his head. A gentle quiver crept into the lower part of his face, so he continued looking down, ashamed of his shame.
The director watched him, still somewhat frustrated, yet sympathetic. “Sam, I had seen something special in you. I thought you might even replace me someday as the director. I’m not as confident that that is still a possibility.” He looked over at Samdel again to see if he reacted; Samdel winced slightly and shyly peered back. “Nonetheless, what you have drawn here is quite interesting, possibly even meaningful.”
Samdel was not sure he had ever heard the word ‘meaningful,’ but he was sure he did not know its meaning.
The designer sensed the confusion in Samdel and asked, “Do you know what that means? – ‘meaningful’ that is? Samdel’s hesitation was answer enough. So, the director decided to explain.
“First, for this drawing to be ‘meaningful’ it is considered to be of value. So, although it is not what I was asking for, I still believe it to have value. Next, it has significance, implications, eloquence, expression. Now, I’d like to know what it expresses for you.” He finished explaining and looked at Samdel, awaiting his response.
Samdel had relaxed a bit during the designers monologue, and he had managed to refrain from letting any tears escape. Samdel was thankful for that. So he began. He told the story, as best as he could, of his afternoon’s attempt at drawing, then the dream, and finally his attempt at drawing the image in the dream. He was frustrated and embarrassed at the inadequacy of his story. At every part he felt he was trying too hard to make an excuse, when the fact of the matter was that he just got side-tracked. He had simply forgotten the assignment because of his dream. So, when he came to the dream in the story he tried to explain it with extra detail, hoping the designer would understand how distracting it was.
He finished his story and was slightly out of breath. He looked to the designer, then away. There was no way to know what reaction he would have.
“Why did you feel the need to draw your dream? It is an interesting dream, for sure; but why did it become so much more interesting than the assignment?”
“I don’t know if I believe in The Cause anymore. I met this man on the way here, a Karstillt, and he extinguishes the stars everyday. If the stars were still lit, there would be no need to light them again in the evening, so what makes lighting the stars any greater a task than extinguishing them? Why is the old Karstillt – all Karstillt – outcast? They’re important too… aren’t they?” He paused, realizing he had gotten off track. Concluding he said, “How can I work for this when I don’t even know if The Cause is real, if it even makes sense?”
The director had listened to Samdel’s little rant. He thought it interesting that Samdel seemed to dodge the question, much the same way he had dodged the assignment. He decided he must be gentle with Samdel – his understanding of the world has been challenged.
“Samdel,” the director said, thinking about Samdel’s concerns. He continued, “to do something for the sake of ‘The Cause’ must mean it has also become your cause. We talked about what it means to be efficient, and I am happy that you are taking it seriously, but is ‘The Cause’ not a decent cause? Maybe it is, maybe it isn’t. At the very least, the answer is not a simple ‘yes’ or ‘no’ – there must be deliberation and thought given. I want you to think about this and ask some questions. Even if you don’t believe there to be an answer, ask the questions. Mostly, don’t try to give yourself an answer too hastily; if the question is worth asking, the answer is worth waiting for.”
“What questions should I ask?”
“That, Sam, is a great first question. Ask it of our first implied question, ‘is “The Cause” a decent cause?’ and see what questions you discern.”
Moving through the dark corridor, Samdel envied all those Larstites running tests. They seemed to know what they believed and why their work was important.
Samdel walked home, slightly confused about the director telling him to question questions rather than answering them. He realized though, that through a lot of this he had not talked to his father since the star-lighting trip.
Walking through the door and entering the living area, he saw his father reclining after his afternoon nap.
“Pops,” Samdel said, “can we talk?”





